After a car accident, you may find yourself without a vehicle for days—or even weeks—while repairs are underway or while you’re negotiating a total loss settlement. During this time, many drivers rely on rental cars to stay mobile. But one question always comes up: Who pays for the rental car, and how much are you really entitled to?

If you’ve never filed an insurance claim before, navigating rental car reimbursement can be confusing. In this article, we break down how it works, when you’re eligible, how long coverage typically lasts, and what to watch out for to ensure you’re not paying out of pocket for something your insurance should cover.

What Is Rental Car Reimbursement?

Rental car reimbursement is an optional coverage in most auto insurance policies that helps cover the cost of a rental car while your vehicle is being repaired due to a covered loss, such as a collision or comprehensive claim (e.g., theft, storm damage).

But even if you don’t have this coverage on your own policy, you may still qualify for a rental car through the at-fault party’s insurance.

Two Main Paths to Rental Coverage

There are two primary ways rental reimbursement works, depending on who was at fault:

1. Through Your Own Insurance (If You Have Rental Coverage)

If you caused the accident or the at-fault driver’s insurer is taking too long to respond, you can rent a vehicle through your own policy if you opted for rental reimbursement coverage.

• Pros: You get the rental right away.

• Cons: You pay upfront and may have to wait for reimbursement, and you’re limited by your policy terms.

Typical rental reimbursement limits:

• $30–$50 per day

• Up to 30 days maximum

2. Through the At-Fault Driver’s Insurance

If the other party is at fault and their insurer accepts liability, they’re responsible for providing you with a comparable rental vehicle while yours is being repaired or replaced.

• Pros: No deductible, no policy limits—you may get a car of similar size and class.

• Cons: It can take several days (or longer) for the insurance company to accept liability, delaying your access to the rental.

What Type of Rental Are You Entitled To?

You are entitled to a vehicle that’s reasonably comparable to your own. For example:

• If you drive an SUV or minivan, you shouldn’t be forced into a compact sedan.

• If your vehicle is used for work (e.g., construction, delivery), the replacement should be equally functional.

Insurers may try to place you in the cheapest option unless you advocate for yourself. Keep records showing why you need a larger or specialized vehicle.

How Long Will Insurance Cover the Rental?

It depends on the situation:

If Your Car Is Being Repaired:

You’re typically covered for the entire time the vehicle is in the shop, as long as the repair delay is reasonable and due to the accident.

If Your Car Is Totaled:

You’re usually covered only until the insurer makes a settlement offer, not until you purchase a new vehicle. This can be as short as 5–7 days after your total loss is confirmed.

Tip: Ask for an extension if you’re actively working on replacing your vehicle, but don’t expect open-ended coverage.

What’s NOT Covered (Unless You’re Careful)

There are a few traps to watch out for:

• Extra fees: Insurance often won’t pay for optional add-ons like insurance waivers, GPS, or toll passes.

• Rental upgrades: If you rent a luxury vehicle beyond your entitlement, you’ll pay the difference out of pocket.

• Rental gaps: If there’s a delay in inspection, repair authorization, or total loss valuation, you may be stuck without a rental while waiting on the insurer.

What If You’re Not Offered a Rental?

Sometimes insurers will delay providing a rental or deny one altogether. Here’s what you can do:

Document Everything

Keep copies of all communications, photos, and repair timelines. If you can show your car is undriveable and repairs are pending, you strengthen your case.

Pay Out of Pocket—Then Request Reimbursement

If you can’t wait, you can rent a car yourself and seek reimbursement later. Just be sure the insurer has already accepted liability, and keep all receipts.

File a Complaint

If the insurer is stalling unfairly, you have the right to file a complaint with your state’s Department of Insurance or seek legal or appraisal support to escalate the matter.

How Commercial Drivers Are Affected

If you drive a vehicle for business—like a box truck, heavy-duty pickup, or equipment-hauling trailer—you may be entitled to loss-of-use compensation instead of or in addition to a rental.

Insurers often ignore this entirely unless you know how to ask. An independent appraisal service can help you document the fair daily rental rate of your work vehicle to ensure you’re compensated for every day you’re sidelined.

Our Advice: Don’t Let Rental Costs Sneak Up On You

We see it all the time: drivers without rental coverage stuck paying for a rental while waiting for adjusters, parts, or total loss settlement delays. Others are offered substandard vehicles or reimbursed at daily rates that don’t match the market.

Here’s how to protect yourself:

• Know what your policy covers before an accident happens.

• If someone else is at fault, insist that their insurer covers a comparable rental.

• Document every day you’re without your car.

• Keep all receipts and rental agreements.

• Ask for extensions if the repair or replacement process drags out.

Final Thoughts

Rental car reimbursement seems straightforward—until it isn’t. Between policy limits, delayed liability decisions, and insurers offering the bare minimum, it’s easy to end up paying out of pocket if you’re not prepared.

Whether you’re handling a repair, a total loss, or a commercial claim, it pays to know your rights. You don’t have to settle for less just because it’s convenient for the insurance company.

Need Help with a Rental Reimbursement or Total Loss Claim?

At Auto Claim Solutions, we help drivers and commercial operators across Georgia, the Carolinas, Florida, and beyond get the compensation they’re entitled to—fast. Whether your vehicle is in the shop or totaled, we fight to make sure your rental car reimbursement is fair, timely, and complete.

Our experts can assist with:

• Total loss valuation

• Diminished value

• Loss of use or downtime compensation

• Commercial and heavy equipment appraisals

Don’t wait until the rental clock runs out. Contact us today for a free claim review and take control of your recovery process.

About the autor: